Our panel of 91 professional philosophers has responded to

2
 questions about 
Action
67
 questions about 
Feminism
68
 questions about 
Happiness
208
 questions about 
Science
54
 questions about 
Medicine
58
 questions about 
Abortion
80
 questions about 
Death
282
 questions about 
Knowledge
218
 questions about 
Education
51
 questions about 
War
392
 questions about 
Religion
88
 questions about 
Physics
374
 questions about 
Logic
1280
 questions about 
Ethics
2
 questions about 
Culture
69
 questions about 
Business
5
 questions about 
Euthanasia
96
 questions about 
Time
58
 questions about 
Punishment
124
 questions about 
Profession
27
 questions about 
Gender
24
 questions about 
Suicide
75
 questions about 
Perception
81
 questions about 
Identity
70
 questions about 
Truth
221
 questions about 
Value
134
 questions about 
Love
154
 questions about 
Sex
110
 questions about 
Biology
105
 questions about 
Art
32
 questions about 
Sport
36
 questions about 
Literature
39
 questions about 
Race
287
 questions about 
Language
170
 questions about 
Freedom
4
 questions about 
Economics
110
 questions about 
Animals
244
 questions about 
Justice
77
 questions about 
Emotion
34
 questions about 
Music
151
 questions about 
Existence
284
 questions about 
Mind
43
 questions about 
Color
31
 questions about 
Space
75
 questions about 
Beauty
574
 questions about 
Philosophy
23
 questions about 
History
89
 questions about 
Law
117
 questions about 
Children

Question of the Day

Einstein gets credit for relativity, but (in spite of his having been a patent clerk) not a patent. Not all innovations are patentable, and in the sciences, philosophy, history... this is a very good thing. If something is patented, then others typically have to pay to use it. That’s not what we want for scientific or philosophical ideas.

What you seem more concerned about is credit, and there the answer is usually straightforward. The person who publishes the idea first generally gets credit. What credit means is just that it will be acknowledged by others that the person getting the credit is the originator of the idea.

But remember that few ideas are thoroughly original, that sometimes a larger idea can be “in the air,” so to speak, with more than one person coming up with a version, and that even if Jo Blow gets “credit,” that doesn’t mean her contribution will end up being the most important; how others develop the idea may be what ends up mattering most.

If you think you have an original philosophical idea, the general advice would be to try getting it published in a philosophy journal. But be warned: the process of getting something accepted for publication is very rigorous. Among other things, the referees will ask themselves whether what you’re saying actually is a new contribution (and trust me: there’s a good chance that it isn’t.) They will also go over the arguments for your thesis with a fine-tooth comb. And they will pay close attention to whether your article makes appropriate contact with the larger philosophical literature. There’s a reason why most published philosophy is written by people who spent years learning their craft.