Is it disrespectful to try and tell somebody that you know their thoughts and

Is it disrespectful to try and tell somebody that you know their thoughts and

Is it disrespectful to try and tell somebody that you know their thoughts and motivations better than they do? For example, to tell an engineer that the real reason they are passionate about engineerng is because they are unable to connect with human beings?

Read another response by Charles Taliaferro
Read another response about Ethics