Do ideas exist independently, out there in the ether, waiting to be discovered. For instance did the idea of the motor car exist say 1000 years ago before any human ever thought of it?
Steve B.
Discovered things seem to exist independently of their discovery (think of uninhabited islands and rare species), while invented things come into existence in the very process of their invention (think of the first light bulb). But even if the first light bulb came into existence when Edison invented it, what about the idea of the light bulb? Did he invent this at the same time, or was it, as you suggest, hanging around for eons just waiting for Edison or some other genius to stumble upon it? It's a great question--and connected at root to venerable metaphysical questions to which, in my view, we still lack satisfactory answers. The issue isn't so much about how we use the concepts of invention and discovery (though this is interesting), but rather about the unsettled status of the "ideas" that we discover/invent. On the one hand, we certainly seem to talk of ideas as things that transcend particular, spatio-temporally located acts of thinking in which they might figure. We might say: George...
- Log in to post comments