ASK A QUESTION
RECENT RESPONSES
CONCEPT CLOUD
- About the site
- Site diary
- AskPhilosophers Group
- AskPhilosophers Fund
- AskPhilosophers Books
- AskPhilosophers Mobile
- All (4145)
- Abortion (50)
- Animals (82)
- Art (81)
- Beauty (55)
- Biology (78)
- Business (55)
- Children (83)
- Color (34)
- Consciousness (38)
- Death (59)
- Education (164)
- Emotion (50)
- Environment (26)
- Ethics (944)
- Euthanasia (2)
- Existence (86)
- Feminism (48)
- Freedom (103)
- Gender (22)
- Happiness (60)
- History (13)
- Identity (62)
- Justice (182)
- Knowledge (199)
- Language (189)
- Law (57)
- Literature (33)
- Logic (238)
- Love (99)
- Mathematics (143)
- Medicine (50)
- Mind (197)
- Music (27)
- Perception (55)
- Philosophers (255)
- Philosophy (427)
- Physics (55)
- Probability (30)
- Profession (94)
- Punishment (39)
- Race (26)
- Rationality (85)
- Religion (274)
- Science (153)
- Sex (114)
- Space (23)
- Sport (28)
- Suicide (19)
- Time (76)
- Truth (43)
- Value (148)
- War (38)
- Panelist Login
| SEE ANOTHER QUESTION |
| in Identity |
Am I the same person today that I was when I was 2 years old?
November 4, 2005
| Response from Amy Kind on November 5, 2005 |
See also the discussion in response to this question.
 PRINT |
 E-MAIL
E-MAIL THIS ENTRY
|
 TRACK
TRACK THIS ENTRY
If you provide your e-mail address, you will be automatically notified whenever this question receives a response. Your e-mail address will not be used for any other purpose, and it will not be given or sold to anyone. |
SHARE
SHARE THIS ENTRY
PERMALINK
Use the following permanent link to refer to this entry: |
RELATED SITES
| Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy | |
| Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy | |
| Early Modern Texts | |
| Some classics of early modern philosophy |
|
| THINK | |
| A periodical of the Royal Institute of Philosophy | |
| Philosophy Now | |
| A magazine of ideas | |
| The Philosophers' Magazine Online | |
| Philosophy from The Philosophers' Magazine | |
| Philosophy Talk | |
| Radio show, audio archives, blog |
|
| Public Ethics Radio | |
| Engages ethicists in discussion of pressing practical dilemmas. |
|
| Philosophy for Kids | |
| Resources for doing philosophy with children |
|
| High-Phi | |
| Supporting philosophical inquiry in American high schools | |
| Teaching Children Philosophy | |
| How to conduct philosophical discussions with elementary school children |
|
I imagine that you've put on a few pounds since then, but you gave the game away with the word "I". You can only use that word to refer to one person, namely yourself. So if there is any person you can describe as "the person I was when I was two", it's the same person as the one you can describe as "the person I am today".
If you want to leave open the question whether a single person has persisted over time occupying the body that you now inhabit, ask it...well, that way. I'm guessing the answer to that one is also yes, unless you're the sort that sends yourselves birthday cards.